Bicknell Business Advisers · Est. 2006

Helpful comments on tax & finance — for property, construction & business

Bicknell Business Advisers · Est. 2006

Helpful comments on tax & finance — for property, construction & business

Self Assessment 2025/26: 15 Common Mistakes That Could Cost You Money

Completing your 2025/26 Self Assessment tax return? Discover 15 common mistakes involving rental expenses, mortgage interest, dividends, tax reliefs and payments on account—and how to avoid paying unnecessary tax before the 31 January 2027 deadline.

Table of Contents

A practical tax return guide for landlords, company directors and the self-employed

By Steve Bicknell FCMA CGMA | Bicknell Business Advisers Limited

From forgotten income and missed tax reliefs to rental property expenses, new company director reporting requirements and unexpected January tax bills, these are 15 mistakes worth checking before submitting your 2025/26 Self Assessment return.

The deadline for submitting your 2025/26 Self Assessment tax return online is 31 January 2027. With January approaching, taxpayers should be gathering their records, reviewing their tax position and checking whether they have claimed all the reliefs to which they are entitled.

Self Assessment is not simply about entering figures into HMRC’s online system. You need to establish which income is taxable, identify the correct expenses and reliefs, account for losses or allowances brought forward, and check that the resulting tax calculation is accurate.

For 2025/26, there are particularly important developments affecting landlords and company directors. These include the abolition of the Furnished Holiday Lettings regime and new disclosure requirements for directors of close companies.

Whether you are a landlord, company director, self-employed professional or someone with several sources of income, the following 15 mistakes could result in unnecessary tax, incorrect returns or HMRC penalties.

1. Forgetting to Declare All Sources of Income

One of the most common Self Assessment mistakes is omitting income that should be included in the return.

This can involve income already taxed under PAYE as well as income received without tax being deducted.

Potentially reportable income includes:

  • Employment income and taxable benefits.
  • Self-employment and freelance profits.
  • UK and overseas rental income.
  • Dividends from limited companies and investments.
  • Bank and building society interest.
  • Certain pension income and taxable lump sums.
  • Income from online trading or other commercial activities.
  • Overseas income where UK reporting is required.

Capital gains should also be considered, although they are distinct from income and are reported under the Capital Gains Tax rules.

Not every receipt is taxable, and some income falls within specific allowances or exemptions. However, you should establish its correct treatment rather than simply leaving it off the return.

Example

A company director receives:

Income sourceAmount
Salary£12,570
Dividends£35,000
Gross rental income£15,000
Bank interest£1,500

All four income sources need to be considered when preparing the return, even though the salary has already been processed through PAYE.

The rental income must then be adjusted for allowable expenditure and any relevant reliefs to establish the taxable property profit.

Practical tip: Reconcile your income against bank statements, dividend vouchers, letting-agent statements, P60s and other supporting documents.

2. Claiming the Wrong Expenses Against Rental Income

Landlords can deduct qualifying expenditure incurred in running their rental property business, but not every property-related payment is allowable.

ExpenseGeneral tax treatment
Letting-agent management feesNormally allowable
Landlord insuranceNormally allowable
Routine repairs and maintenanceNormally allowable
Replacement of an existing boilerPotentially allowable as a repair
Council Tax and utilities paid by the landlordNormally allowable where business-related
Accountancy fees for the rental businessNormally allowable
Purchase of a rental propertyCapital expenditure
Extension or substantial improvementGenerally capital expenditure
Mortgage capital repaymentsNot deductible
Residential mortgage interestSubject to separate finance-cost restriction for individuals

The distinction between repairs and improvements is particularly important.

Replacing an existing kitchen with a broadly equivalent modern kitchen may qualify as a repair. Adding an extension or installing facilities that did not previously exist will generally be capital expenditure.

There can also be complications where major works are carried out immediately after purchasing a property.

HMRC’s Property Rental Toolkit identifies capital versus revenue expenditure, essential repairs to newly acquired properties, dual-purpose expenditure and finance costs as areas where errors commonly arise.

Practical tip: Keep detailed invoices, photographs and specifications for significant refurbishment projects. A single invoice described as “property renovation” may not provide sufficient evidence to support the correct tax treatment.

Rental Property Expenses

3. Deducting Residential Mortgage Interest in Full

Individual landlords of residential property generally cannot deduct mortgage interest directly from their rental profits.

Instead, qualifying finance costs are considered for a basic-rate Income Tax reduction, normally calculated at 20%, subject to statutory limits.

This is commonly known as the Section 24 mortgage interest restriction.

Worked example

DescriptionAmount
Rental income£30,000
Allowable expenses excluding finance costs(£5,000)
Taxable property profit before losses£25,000
Qualifying mortgage interest£12,000
Potential basic-rate tax reduction£2,400

Assuming sufficient property profits, adjusted total income and tax liability, the landlord may receive a £2,400 reduction in their Income Tax liability.

The important point is that the taxable property profit is £25,000, not £13,000.

For higher-rate taxpayers, this can produce a significantly different result from simply deducting mortgage interest from rental profits.

Unused qualifying finance costs may be carried forward where the statutory limits prevent full relief in the current year.

Practical tip: Check the previous year’s tax return for unused finance costs. They are separate from ordinary property losses and should not be overlooked.

4. Missing the Changes to Furnished Holiday Lettings

The special Furnished Holiday Lettings (FHL) tax regime was abolished for Income Tax purposes from 6 April 2025.

Consequently, 2025/26 is the first tax year in which former FHL businesses are generally taxed under the ordinary property income rules.

The changes include:

  • Residential finance-cost restrictions now applying where relevant.
  • The removal of the former FHL capital allowance rules for new qualifying expenditure.
  • Changes to the treatment of furniture and replacement domestic items.
  • The withdrawal of various FHL-specific Capital Gains Tax advantages.
  • Changes to the treatment of FHL income for pension contribution purposes.
  • The application of ordinary jointly owned property income rules.

What happens to former FHL losses?

This is an important transitional issue.

Under the Finance Act 2025 transitional provisions, qualifying unrelieved FHL losses can transfer into the corresponding UK or overseas property business, provided the statutory conditions are met.

These include carrying on the corresponding property business in 2025/26.

The qualifying losses are then treated as losses of that corresponding property business.

They should not simply be discarded because the FHL regime has ended.

Existing qualifying capital allowance pools may also continue to attract writing-down allowances under the transitional rules.

Example

A former holiday cottage generates:

DescriptionAmount
Gross rental income£35,000
Ordinary allowable running expenses(£10,000)
Property profit before losses and other allowances£25,000
Qualifying mortgage interest£8,000
Potential basic-rate finance-cost reduction£1,600

The £8,000 mortgage interest is not simply deducted from the £25,000 property profit.

Instead, the residential finance-cost restriction must be applied, subject to the relevant limits.

Any qualifying former FHL losses and capital allowance pools must also be considered separately.

Jointly owned former FHL properties

Former FHL owners should revisit how rental profits are allocated between joint owners.

The ordinary rules for jointly held property now apply, including the special rules for spouses and civil partners.

Practical tip: If your 2024/25 tax return included FHL income, capital allowance pools or unused losses, review those figures carefully before completing 2025/26.

5. Forgetting Replacement Domestic Items Relief

Landlords of residential properties may qualify for Replacement of Domestic Items Relief when replacing certain items supplied for tenants’ use.

Examples include:

  • Beds and mattresses.
  • Sofas and other movable furniture.
  • Carpets and curtains.
  • Fridges and washing machines.
  • Crockery and kitchenware.

The relief generally applies to replacing an existing domestic item, not initially furnishing a property.

The replacement must be provided solely for the tenant’s use in the dwelling, and the old item must cease to be available for use there.

The amount of relief may include qualifying incidental costs of acquiring or disposing of the item, but must take account of any disposal proceeds received.

An improvement element may also need to be excluded.

Example

A landlord replaces a worn-out sofa with a similar modern sofa costing £900.

The £900 may qualify for relief, subject to the statutory conditions and any proceeds received from disposing of the old sofa.

If the landlord purchases a substantially more expensive upgraded item, the deductible amount may be restricted to the cost of a reasonable modern equivalent.

Practical tip: Keep a record of the original item, its replacement, the cost, any disposal proceeds and the date the replacement was installed.

6. Using the Wrong Accounting Basis for Property Income

For most individual landlords, the cash basis is the default method of calculating property income unless an election or exclusion applies.

For 2025/26, the cash basis is generally available where total UK property income does not exceed £150,000, subject to the detailed rules.

This property-income limit should not be confused with the separate accounting rules for self-employed trading businesses.

Under the cash basis, income is generally recognised when received and eligible expenses when paid.

Traditional accounting, also known as the accruals basis, recognises income when earned and expenses when incurred.

Example: rent paid after the tax year

A tenant owes £1,500 rent for March 2026 but pays it on 10 April 2026.

Under the cash basis, that receipt would normally fall into the 2026/27 tax year.

Under traditional accounting, it would generally be recognised in 2025/26.

The precise payment date matters because the UK tax year ends on 5 April, not 31 March.

Using the wrong accounting basis can result in income being reported in the wrong year or being counted twice.

Practical tip: Check the accounting basis used on your previous return and ensure any change is properly considered, including transitional adjustments.

7. Splitting Joint Rental Income Incorrectly

Jointly owned properties create particular Self Assessment complications.

Married couples and civil partners

For spouses and civil partners living together, income from jointly held property is normally taxed equally under Income Tax Act 2007, section 836.

Where the beneficial ownership is unequal, a valid Form 17 declaration may allow income to be taxed according to the actual beneficial interests.

However, Form 17 does not create a freely chosen tax allocation.

The beneficial interests in the income must correspond to the beneficial interests in the property.

The declaration must:

  • Reflect the actual beneficial ownership.
  • Be supported by the required evidence.
  • Be received by HMRC within 60 days of the declaration.
  • Relate to property held in a form for which the declaration is available.

Form 17 cannot be used where the property is held as beneficial joint tenants.

The declaration generally applies to income arising from its date, not retrospectively to earlier rental income.

Example

A married couple jointly owns a rental property producing £20,000 of taxable rental profit.

Without a relevant exception or valid Form 17 declaration, the normal allocation is £10,000 to each spouse.

Simply paying the rent into one spouse’s bank account does not automatically change the tax treatment.

Unmarried joint owners

Different rules apply to unmarried co-owners.

HMRC’s Property Income Manual at PIM4190 recognises that joint owners may agree a different division of property business profits and losses.

However, the tax allocation must reflect the arrangement actually agreed and implemented.

It should not be a retrospective allocation selected merely to minimise tax when preparing the returns.

Practical tip: Review property ownership, declarations of trust, actual profit-sharing arrangements and any existing Form 17 declarations before completing the return.

8. Overlooking Property Losses and Finance Costs Brought Forward

A rental property may have made losses in previous years because of repairs, vacancies or other allowable expenses.

Qualifying UK property business losses can generally be carried forward against future profits of the same property business.

However, ordinary property losses and unused residential finance costs are different tax attributes.

They should be recorded separately.

Example

A landlord has £8,000 of qualifying property losses brought forward and makes a £15,000 property profit in 2025/26.

Subject to the applicable rules, the brought-forward losses reduce the taxable property profit to £7,000.

Failing to carry forward the losses could result in the landlord paying more tax than necessary.

Former FHL losses require particular attention because of the transitional provisions following abolition.

Practical tip: Compare your current return with the previous year’s computations and supporting loss schedules.

9. Forgetting Dividends, Confusing Director’s Loans and Missing New Director Disclosures

Company directors sometimes assume that all money withdrawn from their company is either salary or dividends.

That is not necessarily correct.

Withdrawals may represent:

  • Salary processed through payroll.
  • Dividends supported by appropriate company records.
  • Repayments of money previously lent to the company.
  • Director’s loan account transactions.
  • Reimbursement of business expenses.
  • Interest paid on qualifying loans.

These have different tax consequences.

For 2025/26, the dividend allowance is £500. Technically, this is income charged at the dividend nil rate, rather than income excluded altogether from the tax calculation.

Example

A director withdraws £40,000 from their company during the year.

The company records show £30,000 in properly declared dividends and £10,000 repaying an existing director’s loan credit balance.

The two amounts require different treatment on the director’s personal tax return.

Important new reporting requirements for 2025/26

There are additional disclosure requirements for company directors completing Self Assessment returns for 2025/26.

Where applicable, directors must provide information about their directorships and whether the company is a close company.

For a relevant close company, the additional information includes:

  • The company’s name.
  • Its registered company number.
  • The amount of dividends received from that company.
  • The percentage of the company’s share capital owned by the director.

These requirements are particularly relevant to owner-managed limited companies.

A close company is broadly one controlled by five or fewer participators, or by participators who are directors, subject to the statutory definition.

The additional reporting requirements are supported by legislation introduced through SI 2025/84.

A specific £60 penalty can apply for failures to provide the required additional information correctly.

Being a company director does not, by itself, mean that a Self Assessment return must be submitted. However, directors who are required to file must ensure that the new relevant disclosures are completed.

Practical tip: Reconcile dividend vouchers, company accounts, director’s loan balances and shareholding records. Directors should also ensure their accountant has the company registration number and details of their shareholding.

Dividends and Directors Loans

10. Missing Pension Contributions and Other Tax Reliefs

Taxpayers can overlook reliefs because they assume pension contributions or charitable donations have already been fully reflected in their tax calculations.

For example, personal pension contributions made under a relief-at-source arrangement normally receive basic-rate relief within the pension scheme.

Higher-rate and additional-rate taxpayers may be entitled to further relief through Self Assessment.

Gift Aid donations can also affect the calculation of higher-rate tax relief.

Other reliefs may apply in specific circumstances, including qualifying loan interest, certain employment expenses and relevant trading losses.

Example

A taxpayer makes a net personal pension contribution of £8,000 to a relief-at-source pension scheme.

The pension provider adds £2,000 basic-rate relief, creating a £10,000 gross contribution.

Depending on the taxpayer’s circumstances, further relief may be available through Self Assessment.

The precise relief depends on the taxpayer’s income and applicable tax rates. Scottish taxpayers may have different rates and relief calculations.

Practical tip: Obtain pension contribution statements and Gift Aid records, and check whether the amounts entered should be gross or net.

11. Ignoring the High Income Child Benefit Charge

The High Income Child Benefit Charge (HICBC) can apply where an individual or their partner receives Child Benefit and the higher earner’s adjusted net income exceeds the relevant threshold.

For 2025/26, the charge begins when adjusted net income exceeds £60,000 and reaches the full amount of Child Benefit at £80,000.

A common mistake is assuming that Child Benefit does not matter because it was paid to the other partner.

The liability can fall on the higher-income partner rather than the person who receives the benefit.

Another mistake is overlooking the effect of pension contributions and Gift Aid donations on adjusted net income.

Example

A taxpayer has adjusted net income of £70,000.

They are halfway through the £60,000–£80,000 HICBC band, so the charge is generally 50% of the relevant Child Benefit, subject to the detailed rules.

Some taxpayers may be able to pay the charge through PAYE rather than Self Assessment. The correct reporting and payment route should be checked.

Practical tip: Review household Child Benefit and the adjusted net income of both partners before finalising the return.

12. Failing to Report Capital Gains or Reconcile a 60-Day Property Return

Capital Gains Tax is another area where taxpayers can make expensive mistakes.

Selling a second home, investment property, shares or certain other assets may create a chargeable gain.

For 2025/26, the annual exempt amount for most individuals is £3,000.

The ordinary Capital Gains Tax rates for individuals are generally 18% and 24%, depending on the applicable tax bands and the nature of the gain.

UK residential property disposals may also require a separate Capital Gains Tax return and payment within 60 days of completion.

This is a separate reporting obligation and should not be left until the annual Self Assessment deadline.

Submitting a 60-day return does not necessarily remove the need to reflect the disposal correctly in Self Assessment.

Example

A landlord sells a buy-to-let property and submits a 60-day CGT return, paying £12,000 in Capital Gains Tax.

When preparing the annual Self Assessment return, the disposal and the £12,000 already paid must be reconciled where the gain is reportable on the return.

Otherwise, the tax computation may be incorrect.

Practical tip: Retain purchase and sale completion statements, legal fees, qualifying enhancement expenditure and details of any CGT already paid.

13. Overlooking Overseas Income and Foreign Tax Relief

UK-resident taxpayers may need to declare overseas income, including:

  • Rental income from overseas properties.
  • Foreign dividends.
  • Overseas bank interest.
  • Foreign pensions.
  • Certain employment or self-employment income.

Foreign income can be taxable in more than one country, although double taxation relief may be available.

The correct treatment depends on residence, the type of income, applicable tax treaties and any special UK tax regime that applies.

Important changes from 6 April 2025

The former remittance basis regime was replaced by a new foreign income and gains (FIG) regime from 6 April 2025.

Eligible individuals who are newly UK resident after a qualifying period of non-UK residence may be able to claim relief on certain foreign income and gains during their first four years of UK residence.

There are detailed eligibility conditions, claim requirements and transitional provisions.

The rules are particularly important for individuals moving to the UK from overseas.

Taxpayers who previously used the remittance basis should not assume that the same treatment continues for 2025/26.

Practical tip: Obtain foreign tax statements, confirm the taxpayer’s residence position and calculate any foreign tax credit relief using the relevant rules.

14. Misunderstanding Payments on Account

One of the biggest surprises for taxpayers is discovering that their January Self Assessment bill includes more than the tax due for the previous year.

Payments on account are advance payments towards the next tax year’s Income Tax and, where applicable, Class 4 National Insurance.

They are generally required where the relevant previous-year liability is at least £1,000, unless more than 80% of the tax was collected outside Self Assessment.

Each payment is normally half of the relevant previous-year liability.

Capital Gains Tax is not included in the normal payments-on-account calculation.

Worked example: Why a £6,000 tax bill can become £9,000

Assume a taxpayer has a £6,000 unpaid Income Tax and Class 4 National Insurance liability for 2025/26.

For this example, the entire £6,000 is relevant to the payments-on-account calculation, with no tax deducted at source or other adjustments affecting that calculation.

The taxpayer has made no payments on account towards 2025/26.

PaymentDue dateAmount
2025/26 balancing payment31 January 2027£6,000
First payment on account for 2026/2731 January 2027£3,000
Total payable in January31 January 2027£9,000
Second payment on account for 2026/2731 July 2027£3,000

The taxpayer therefore pays £9,000 in January and a further £3,000 in July.

Of the total £12,000, £6,000 settles the previous year’s liability and £6,000 represents advance payments towards 2026/27.

If income has genuinely fallen, it may be appropriate to apply to reduce payments on account.

However, reducing them too far can result in interest being charged.

Practical tip: Check both the current-year tax liability and the next year’s payments on account before agreeing the return.

January tax bills and payments on account

15. Filing Late, Paying Late or Failing to Check the Final Return

The final mistake is treating the Self Assessment deadline as the only important date.

For 2025/26, the main deadlines are:

RequirementDeadline
Register for Self Assessment where requiredNormally 5 October 2026
Submit a paper return31 October 2026
Submit online if seeking eligible PAYE tax-code collection30 December 2026
Submit the online tax return31 January 2027
Pay the balancing liability and first payment on account31 January 2027
Pay the second payment on account31 July 2027

Special filing deadlines can apply in particular circumstances, including some late registrations.

However, a later filing deadline following late registration does not automatically postpone the normal payment deadline of 31 January 2027.

Late filing can result in an initial £100 penalty, with further penalties potentially arising where the delay continues.

Late payment can also lead to interest and additional penalties.

Even where the return is submitted on time, it is important to check that HMRC has received it and that the payment has been allocated correctly.

Practical tip: Review the complete tax calculation, including payments already made, before authorising submission.


Final tax return review

Self Assessment 2025/26: Final Checklist

Before submitting your return, consider the following:

  • Have all reportable sources of income been included?
  • Have you reconciled income to bank statements and supporting records?
  • Have rental expenses been correctly classified?
  • Have you applied the residential finance-cost restriction?
  • Have you checked former FHL losses and capital allowance pools?
  • Have you claimed qualifying replacement domestic items relief?
  • Have you used the correct accounting basis?
  • Have you allocated jointly owned rental income correctly?
  • Have you included brought-forward losses and unused finance costs?
  • Have you reconciled dividends and director’s loan accounts?
  • Have you completed any new close-company director disclosures?
  • Have you claimed relevant pension and Gift Aid relief?
  • Have you considered the High Income Child Benefit Charge?
  • Have you included relevant capital gains and CGT payments?
  • Have you reviewed overseas income and foreign tax relief?
  • Have you checked payments on account and the final amount payable?

Frequently Asked Questions

When is the Self Assessment deadline for 2025/26?

The deadline for submitting an online 2025/26 Self Assessment tax return is 31 January 2027. Any balancing tax liability is also generally due by that date.

Can I submit my tax return before January 2027?

Yes. The return can be submitted before the deadline once you have the necessary information. Filing early gives you more time to check the calculation and budget for the tax payment.

What happens if I make a mistake on my Self Assessment return?

You can normally amend an online Self Assessment return within the statutory amendment window. For a 2025/26 return, the usual amendment deadline is 31 January 2028.

Older errors may require a different correction or disclosure process.

Do I need Self Assessment if I am a company director?

Being a company director does not, by itself, mean that a Self Assessment return is required.

The position depends on your income, tax circumstances and whether HMRC has issued a notice requiring a return.

However, directors who are required to file for 2025/26 should check the new reporting requirements, particularly where they are directors of close companies.

What if I cannot afford my January tax bill?

HMRC may agree a Time to Pay arrangement where the relevant conditions are met. Contact HMRC promptly rather than ignoring the liability.

Making Tax Digital: Already Underway for Some Landlords and Sole Traders

Making Tax Digital for Income Tax (MTD) is no longer simply a future change.

The first mandatory cohort started on 6 April 2026, and the next group is due to join from 6 April 2027.

The timetable is:

Start dateQualifying income thresholdTax year used to assess income
6 April 2026Over £50,0002024/25
6 April 2027Over £30,0002025/26
6 April 2028Over £20,0002026/27

These thresholds are based on qualifying gross income from self-employment and property, not taxable profits after expenses.

Example: landlord and sole trader

A taxpayer has:

Income sourceGross income
Rental income£25,000
Self-employment turnover£12,000
Total qualifying income£37,000

The combined qualifying income exceeds the £30,000 threshold by £7,000.

Subject to the detailed eligibility and exemption rules, the taxpayer will therefore be required to join MTD from 6 April 2027.

This makes accurate reporting of 2025/26 gross income particularly important.

The first quarterly deadlines have already passed

For taxpayers who joined MTD in April 2026, the first quarterly update was due on 7 August 2026.

The second was due on 7 November 2026.

The next deadlines are:

  • 7 February 2027.
  • 7 May 2027.

HMRC has confirmed that no late quarterly-update penalty points will be applied for the 2026/27 tax year.

However, this does not remove the obligation to maintain digital records and submit quarterly updates.

Taxpayers must still complete the required updates before submitting their annual tax return through compatible software.

Practical tip: Landlords and sole traders with qualifying income above £30,000 in 2025/26 should review their MTD position now rather than waiting until April 2027.

How Bicknell Business Advisers Can Help

At Bicknell Business Advisers Limited, we assist landlords, property investors, company directors and self-employed individuals with Self Assessment returns and related tax planning.

Our work includes:

  • Reviewing rental income and allowable expenses.
  • Checking residential finance-cost restrictions.
  • Dealing with former furnished holiday lettings and transitional balances.
  • Reconciling dividend and director’s loan information.
  • Completing the new close-company director disclosures.
  • Identifying relevant tax reliefs and losses.
  • Reviewing capital gains and overseas income.
  • Preparing taxpayers for Making Tax Digital.

If you need assistance with your 2025/26 Self Assessment return, please contact us at www.bicknells.net.

Existing clients who have not yet supplied their information should complete our 2025/26 Self Assessment questionnaire as soon as possible.

This article provides general information about UK taxation for the 2025/26 tax year, updated on 20 November 2026. Individual circumstances, statutory exceptions and residence may affect the treatment. Professional advice should be obtained before making decisions or submitting a return.

Further Reading and Official Guidance

About the Author

Steve Bicknell FCMA, CGMA is Managing Director of Bicknell Business Advisers Limited, specialising in property taxation, landlord tax planning, SDLT, Capital Gains Tax and property company structures throughout the UK.

Facebook
X
LinkedIn
Pinterest
Tumblr
Threads
Telegram
WhatsApp

Explore More...